| 1939 |
Dave Kribs, HB |
| 1940 |
Horace Coleman, HB |
| 1941 |
Horace Coleman, HB |
| 1942 |
Bill Yambrick, C |
| 1943 |
August Camarata, FB |
| 1944 |
Glenn Rodney, OT |
| 1945 |
Ned Stuits, OT |
| 1946 |
Allen Bush, HB |
| 1947 |
Emerson Grossman, OG |
| 1948 |
Hilton Foster, QB |
| 1949 |
George Dunn, S |
| 1950 |
Bill Zabonick, E |
| 1951 |
Ron Gow, OG |
| 1952 |
Willard Brown, HB |
| 1953 |
Leslie Koster, OT |
| 1954 |
Jack Kelder, OT |
| 1955 |
Charles Nidiffer, FB |
| 1956 |
John Berryman, E-T |
| 1957 |
Joe Grigg, E |
| 1958 |
Lovell Coleman, FB |
| 1959 |
Clarence Cheatham, OG |
| 1960 |
Jim Habel, OT |
| 1961 |
Ed Chlebek, QB |
| 1962 |
Bill Schlee, FB |
| 1963 |
Bill Somerville, E |
| 1964 |
Jim Reid, C |
| 1965 |
Bob Rowe, OT |
| 1966 |
Bob Rowe, OT |
| 1967 |
Marty Barski, SE |
| 1968 |
Dave Hudson, DHB |
| 1969 |
Mike Siwek, DT |
| 1970 |
Roger Lawson, FB |
| 1971 |
Tom Elias, LB |
| 1972 |
Dominic Riggio, LB |
| 1973 |
Dominic Riggio, LB |
| 1974 |
Dan Matthews, HB |
| 1975 |
Dan Matthews, FB |
| 1976 |
Jerome Persell, TB |
| 1977 |
Jerome Persell, TB |
| 1978 |
Jerome Persell, TB |
| 1979 |
Matt Murphy, DT |
| 1980 |
George Bullock, DHB |
| 1981 |
Bob Phillips, SE |
| 1982 |
Mark Kujacznski, DHB |
| 1983 |
Shawn Faulkner, TB |
| 1984 |
John Offerdahl, LB |
| 1985 |
John Offerdahl, LB |
| 1986 |
Mark Garalczyk, DT |
| 1987 |
Eric Hoffman, LB |
| 1988 |
Tony Kimbrough, QB |
| 1989 |
Joel Smeenge, DE |
| 1990 |
Sean Mulhearn, LB |
| 1991 |
Greg Kelley, LB |
| 1992 |
Paul Hutchins, OT |
| 1993 |
Jay McDonagh, QB |
| 1994 |
Jay McDonagh, QB |
| 1995 |
Jay McDonagh, QB |
|
Jim Vackaro, HB |
| 1996 |
Tony Knox, WR |
| 1997 |
Tarrence McEvans, SS |
| 1998 |
Tim Lester, QB |
| 1999 |
Tim Lester, QB |
| 2000 |
Garrett Soldano, LB |
| 2001 |
Bryan Lape, LB |
| 2002 |
Jason Feldpausch, WS |
| 2003 |
Jason Feldpausch, WS |
| 2004 |
Greg Jennings, WR |
| 2005 |
Greg Jennings, WR |
| 2006 |
Ameer Ismail, LB |
| 2007 |
Jamarko Simmons, WR |
| 2008 |
Tim Hiller, QB |
| 2009 |
Tim Hiller, QB |
| 2010 |
Jordan White, WR |
| 2011 |
Jordan White, WR |
| 2012 |
Freddie Bishop, DE |
| 2013 |
Corey Davis, WR |
| 2014 |
Jarvion Franklin, RB |
| 2015 |
Corey Davis, WR |
|
Daniel Braverman, WR |
| 2016 |
Zach Terrell, QB |
| 2017 |
Jarvion Franklin, RB |
| 2018 |
John Keenoy, C |
| 2019Â Â Â Â |
LeVante Bellamy, RB |
* Renamed Bill Brown Most Outstanding Player Award in 2013 |